Rot (Red)
 
 
Studio: Stevo78
 
Review Count: 152
Average Rating: 4.46 stars
Genre: Romance
Length: 2 minutes 56 seconds
 
Posted on: December 12, 2005
 
 
Film Description
German Voiceover / English subtitles

Melancholic work against the death penalty.
What do you think about, if you donīt have much longer to live? Perhaps about your favorite colour... who knows?

Dedicated to Stanley "Tookie" Williams, executed and declared dead on December 13, 2005 at 12:35 a.m. PST, and all those human beings, who await their death penalty.

--------------------------------------

A statement to the english subtitles:

I am sorry that the subtitles are a bit of an annoyance. I had to make the decision wether I concentrate on combining the subtitles with the pictures or the music with the pictures. I decided to focus my priorities on the music, because itīs more decisive for the movie in my opinion. Please regard that fact when you rate my movie. Thank you!
 
Featured Reviews
- lostwolfnesbit

Originality - ***** Something new for me, letting us see into a condemned man's heart.
Dialogue - ***** I didn't understand a word of the VO, but the subtitles let me know that the dialogue was good, each line leading to the next.
Storyline - ***** I enjoyed it, you knew what you wanted and you accomplished it.
Special effects/sound effects - No Stars, but you didn't need either one or the other for this film, so it won't count against you. The film worked better without them.
Overall - ***** As I said, very original and touching. If we could only see into a condemned man's heart everytime, maybe then we could know what motivates them to do what they did.

Posted on December 15, 2005
- nakedyegg

This is the first movie that i have seen here that made my heart stop. I do not agree with your political views, but I feel your power behind them. Excelent job. Excelent

Posted on December 14, 2005
- Willy-Wonka

Hey, das ist wieder mal filmerische Top-Qualität - vor allem diese Stimmung ist einfach brilliant eingefangen. Die Sprachaufnahmen haben 'ne schöne Qualität, nur klingt da etwas der Dialekt (der Sauerlands?) durch. Die Musik fügte sich auch perfekt ein, das konnte mich richtig begeistern. Kleinliche Kritik, aber ich muss sie loswerden: Vereinzelt (ich hatte den Eindruck, dass du langsam monotoner wurdest, weil das Satzschema sich wiederholte) hätte der Sprache teilweise noch eine etwas gefühlvollere Betonung, mehr Schauspielerei, gut getan. Am Ende machst du das perfekt, da bringst du die Emotion hervorragend rüber, der ganze Schlu�? ist genial.

Da muss man wirklich nicht lange überlegen: Verdiente 5 Sterne!

Posted on December 14, 2005
- cowmansr

Quite powerful. I agree that the subtitles were a bit of an annoyance, making me frequently pause the movie. I don't know how well this could have been avoided though. For bias: I am in most circumstances somewhat opposed to the death penalty. I do wonder in what states this man would have recieved the death penalty for this crime though. Also, I always wonder in these cases why the US is divided as it is, with conservatives being opposed to killing the unborn, but in favor of killing criminals, and liberals into killing the unborn, but wanting to spare the criminals. Why does nobody seek to spare all human life?

Posted on December 14, 2005
- Electronica

This is the first movie since 'The French Revolution' which really touched me. Very powerful and poetic. The script is a real winner.

Posted on December 13, 2005
- YONDERBOY

Artistically, that was very, very good. Technically, however, the subtitles were pretty darn bad. For subtitles, timing is everything. Having subtitles last for less than 1 second or pop in a half-moment before the fade-out is very disruptive.
Work on that.
However, I really enjoyed the poetry of the movie. You get 5 stars for just how great it was. Next time though, I can't be as generous if the technical aspect isn't up to snuff.

Posted on December 13, 2005
- Dark_Mace

That was really beautiful. Great work there. Loved the fades to red and back, great use of custom backdrops all round...and creative use of standards scenes for something seemingly different.

Posted on December 12, 2005
 
Reviews
- uwe1965

Hervorragender Film!!!!

Schau doch auch bitte meinen neuesten.Grazia reitet wieder!
http://movies.lionhead.com/movie/41782

Posted on January 15, 2006
- Slider2010

das ist der beste film den ich bis jetzt hier gesehen habe, da kann man sich mal eine scheibe von abschneiden!
dein film ist sehr tiefgründig...einfach nur klasse ein

!!MEISTERWERK!!

schau dir meine filme doch auch an empfehle 10 gebote und w-unit da movie! am besten schaust du alle an, danke soweit...

Posted on January 5, 2006
- Number12

Ein wirklich Hammer Film.
Der hat wirklich mein Herz gebrochen!
Schau dir mal meine Doku an!
http://movies.lionhead.com/movie/35043

Posted on January 3, 2006
- jacksonj04

Powerful, well written.

Posted on January 3, 2006
- Moonlord1

1a Clip um mal wieder zum Leben zurückzufinden.

Posted on January 3, 2006
- goodmoviecritic

Bravo!Other than the subtitles which you wrote about in your statements that was top notch work!That made me sad, which is a very good sign!Whenever you make a new picture contact me at patricksanders1313@msn.com.

Posted on January 2, 2006
- Rotpar

No comment

Posted on January 2, 2006
- ragarock

simply beautiful!

Posted on January 2, 2006
- Faith303

Echt gut! 5 Sterne von mir!

Posted on January 2, 2006
- Dennis22

Suuuuuuuuuper toll
Eindeutig 5 Sterne, besser geht es wirklich nicht!!!!! Mach weiter so!!!!

Posted on January 2, 2006
- Logo17490

Echt gut, gute Story und noch bessere Umsetzung, man glaubt kaum was alles rot ist^^
War schön anzusehen!!!

Schau bitte auch mein Film: Lang lebe Amerika an :)

Posted on January 2, 2006
- JoanBiel

echt gut! nur die stimme ist etwas schlecht...

Posted on January 2, 2006
- mercian

No comment

Posted on January 1, 2006
- Geordiemovies

A Masterpiece!

Posted on January 1, 2006
- IceJack80

solid work

Posted on January 1, 2006
- WTS

hm... hab n bisschen gänsehaut bekommen. war hute arbeit, nur die Blenden sidn n bissl nervig, könnet man auch anders lösen, aber alles in allem sehr gute arbeit.

Posted on January 1, 2006
- Chris05

1A

Posted on December 31, 2005
- Svenskicorp

Original, excellent

Posted on December 31, 2005
- Zachoo

Powerful and Moving...i congratulate you. I know you will bring a whole new perspective for people in this world. Just dont give up.

Peace out

Zach,
Zachoo Films

Posted on December 30, 2005
- JustinAS00001

I enjoyed this on a few levels. I agree with the message brought fourth from this work. I also liked that it was spoken in german. Being American it gives it a differnet feel about it. Powerful and makes one think about the world that we live in.

Posted on December 29, 2005
- BadJokeDude

gro�?artig... einfach schlicht und ergreifend gro�?artig
beste was ich mir bis jetz angeguckt hab und wahrscheinlich auch besser als alles was ich noch machen werde.

Posted on December 29, 2005
- Omega4u

Super Idee , die düstere stimmung ist bei mir sehr gut rüber gekommen .
Spizenklasse , diene stimme mit der hintergrundmusik !

Posted on December 29, 2005
- virusX

war ganz in ordnung mach weiter so !

Posted on December 28, 2005
- Robin-the-BIG

nicht schlecht

Posted on December 27, 2005
- gnatquill

brilliant, i thought this peice was very touching and i aggree with lostwolfnesbit about the thoughts of a condemned men.

Posted on December 26, 2005
- RolandHulme

Good job.

Posted on December 26, 2005
- Skyshadowkitty

Amazing movie! Alittle depressing but otherwise it was great! Subtitles were alittle off but I just listened to the voiceover. Anyway great job!

Posted on December 25, 2005
- Retcliffe

Ja, das stimmt. Der Satz "all these things will be lost, like tears in rain. Time.. to die." ist von Rutger Hauer aus dem Film "Bladerunner", aber trotzdem ist dein Film klasse gemacht und verdient 4 Sterne.

Posted on December 25, 2005
- Jimmus

Red were my cheeks when I realized I sat through the entire thing. Obviously nobody has seen Blade Runner, which you stole your ending quote from.

Posted on December 25, 2005
- MattyB667

Very poetic, I liked it.

Posted on December 24, 2005
- TrulyMammoth

Great movie. Very well put together.

Posted on December 23, 2005
- malkian85

This movie is fantastic. One of the best movie i've seen so far.

Posted on December 23, 2005
- Olyver

its a premiere

Posted on December 22, 2005
- Tal0n

klasse film
seht euch bitte meine filme an
http://movies.lionhead.com/movie/24385

Posted on December 22, 2005
- cowboydan76

I disagree with the point of view the film espouses, but it's a beautiful and touching vision. You are a true artist, sir. I liked your use of the "Who Wants to Live Forever" instrumental, as well.

Posted on December 21, 2005
- justinragsdale

Deffinately "Who Wants Too Live Forever" by Queen playing in the back there...And yeah the last line was from "Bladerunner". Couldn't really read the end, so hopefully you gave props too those you borrowed from. All in all a good movie, just a little too bleak (there is no light) for my taste.

Posted on December 21, 2005
- NINJA121

The music is very effective and creates emotion *Sob*. The voice over and speech was amazing, to bad I can't speak German.

Posted on December 21, 2005
- BurtisaWord

ich finde ein origineller und wirklich guter film ist dir da gelungen - es muss nicht immer lustig, treibend oder "cool" sein was sich abspielt, auch was nachdenkliches ist eine willkommene abwechslung. die bilder/szenen sind richtig gut gewählt, aber leider ist das Text- bzw. Sprachschema (wie auch ein anderer in seinem review schon meinte) etwas zu eintönig gewählt... mehr variation hätte gut getan ("rot" muss nicht immer nur am satz anfang stehen) Darum ist für mich der gesamteindruck etwas geschmälert (daher "nur" 4 sterne), was aber die originalität des films und den transport der message nicht schmälert!

Posted on December 21, 2005
- foid

Great VO and idea.

Posted on December 21, 2005
- Kikinator

wow super leistung

ich habe noch nie einen film gesehen,wo das ende so kurz ist und gleichzeitig soviel aussagt!!!
BRAVO!

Posted on December 21, 2005
- casanova

Bello....rosso.

Posted on December 21, 2005
- KidSlug

Was soll ich andere sagen als genial! ich habe die erste Version geratet und diese rate ich ebenflls!
Geil von dir den Film Tookie zu widmen.

Posted on December 20, 2005
- pvtjoker

I would have rated you a hell of a lot higher if you hadn't ripped off the fantastic speach from the end of 'Bladerunner'. It was Roy who said, "all these things will be lost, like tears in rain. Time.. to die." Sorry fella', but plajurism is just not fair play. You could at least have credited the line in the synopsis.
Such a shame really, it's a very nice film other than that. A touch sentimental, but then thats me being a snob. The above score is for your thievery, other than that I'd certainly give you four stars.

Posted on December 20, 2005
- le_nouvelle_cinema

Junge, Junge, da hast du dir ein ziemlich kontroverses Thema ausgesucht!
Grade deswegen erhältst du auch von mir die volle Punktzahl.
Wäre klasse, wenn man Arnie den Film per Mail zukommen lassen könnte.
Weiter so

Posted on December 19, 2005
- gubaguba

I would declare this movie: "The Movie Of The Year"

Posted on December 19, 2005
- kinesis916

yeh thats good. i think it really needed a better soundtrack in the backround but other than that i enjoyed it.

Posted on December 19, 2005
- BobbyWadd1

Very atmospheric with good manipulation of the sets but my eyes started closing with each fade.

Posted on December 19, 2005
- rjb2112

Whether you agree with the message or not. This movie is a must see. It taps into very deep and personal emotions. Did it change my opinion of the death penalty? No, because it is not something I think about often. I live in a country with no death penalty. But this film has made me think about it, and being as I have done that. The writer has acheived his objective, to get people thinking and talking about this very complex and emotive issue. Well done

Posted on December 19, 2005
- JPaterson000

Very, very good movie. I haven't seen one as provocative as yours. The writing was fantastic, and while I don't understand a single word of German, the voice sounded very real, very sad. Great movie, man, great movie. Most definitely five stars. Too bad we can't rate on a one to ten scale.

Posted on December 19, 2005
- TheIcen1974

Great movie, very well put together.

Posted on December 18, 2005
- mrhoeivo

Wow, that was definitely one of the best movies Ive seen on this site. Perfect the whole way through. It was very powerful and moving. It was like a perfect poem turned video. The only minor complaint I have is that the captions were a little fast, but thats not important. Fantanstic.

Posted on December 18, 2005
- NeoManic

Poetry in motion, beautiful. And I love the VO :)

Posted on December 18, 2005
- calvin9999

Didn't really work for me I'm afraid, don't know why!

Posted on December 18, 2005
- hax85

Ein sehr guter Film!

Posted on December 18, 2005
- jackalbane

A movie with great power and great direction. Perfect execution of starting from the end, going to the beginning, and returning to a final ending. Wish the subtitles were somewhat longer, but that's a minor problem. Very well done.

Posted on December 18, 2005
- Cult_Inc

Good movie, very poetic. The subtitles seemed out of synch, perhaps a result of making a cut after the subtitles had been done. Still worked as a movie.

Posted on December 18, 2005
- Kesti

Very nice movie on a very difficult subject.
The only problem was the editing with way too many fades.

Posted on December 18, 2005
- JumpyMonky

Great movie, don't agree with the message, but still very well done.

Posted on December 18, 2005
- blacktest

top noch.
my sister saw this and startred to cry

Posted on December 18, 2005
- MortalMadMatt

Great movie about a very serious issue.

Posted on December 18, 2005
- MoviesManiac

Powerful, though the subtitles were irratating.

Posted on December 18, 2005
- XVI

Gefällt mir wirklich gut der Film.

Posted on December 18, 2005
- capemedia

Good movie, was the music "Who wants to live forever" by Queen I wonder? Hope you have sorted the permissions out. The movie was stirring stuff well done.

Posted on December 18, 2005
- JKjunior

Toller film. Hat mich beeidruckt. Weiter so.

--
JKjunior
www.themovies-resource.net.tf

Posted on December 18, 2005
- sarek13

great

Posted on December 18, 2005
- kevonski

No comment

Posted on December 18, 2005
- Grispi

Poetisch und dramatisch! Ein der Besten Filme. Musik ist sehr brilliant. Dafür gibts von mir 5 Sternen! Romantisch auch nicht zu vergessen!

Posted on December 18, 2005
- Scorch6744

Nice message, powerful

Posted on December 17, 2005
- UrinatingTree

Very compelling and powerful. I liked the poetic style in which you presented the material of red.

And you forgot one comparison... "Red is the color of my hair as it flows through the breeze."

Great work and good luck with your future movies.

Posted on December 17, 2005
- jailerjeff

Editing could have been better, but the story was nice. I don't agree with the films message (dedicating movie to a man who founded one of the most violent gangs in U.S. history?) I would find it absurd to think someone would get the death penalty for this crime. People that are opposed to the death penalty should really talk to the victims families of these crimes (I always wondered how many protesters at these executions have lost a loved one to a violent act).

Posted on December 17, 2005
- Yogurt_King

Great film. Gave me goosebumps. Excellent editing, though I sympathize with you on the problem of fades in this game. Poetry. I commend you on the English subtitles. You only lost a star for one reason - you stole that line, "lost like tears in rain," from Blade Runner and you didn't give credit. Gotta be truthful, man.

Regards, and a job well done.

Posted on December 17, 2005
- Aoimtxvzlmser

Eine gute Idee, die jedoch nicht so hervorragend umgesetzt wurde, wie sie es verdient hat. Die erste Hälfte des "Filmes" gefällt mir nicht. Es wirkt ein bisschen aufgesetzt, besonders auch wegen der lustlos wirkenden Synchro. Aber die zweite Hälfte des Filmes ist sehr gut gemacht.
Wegen der guten Idee, der genialen Aussage und der guten zweiten Hälfte gibt es daher 4 Sterne von mir.

Posted on December 17, 2005
- Nemek

Ganz gro�?es Kino. Wirklich äu�?erst emotional und gefühlvoll inszeniert. Auch das Voiceover ist recht gut gelungen. Die Musik hat das alles natürlich perfekt unter stützt. Na gut, der Song ist geklaut (Who Wants To Live Forever - Queen), aber das stört hier nicht im geringsten.
Der Film ist klasse und hat mir eine Gänsehaut verschafft. Sehr gute Arbeit.
Unter fünf Sternen läuft da ja mal gar nichts.

Posted on December 17, 2005
- Lorgod

Guter Film mit einer schönen Aussage, aber irgendwie fehlte das gewisse Etwas.

Posted on December 17, 2005
- Sebie552

Ein guter Film der eine tolle Stimmung erzeugt! Au�?erdem besitzt er einen wirklich guten Filmschnitt!

Posted on December 17, 2005
- animeabe

I really liked it, very artistic. I wasnt really crazy about the editing in parts like the constant fades but I know its what we have to work with. Overall really good.

Posted on December 17, 2005
- Augie64

I try not to debate polotics in reviews. It just leads to arguments and unfair ratings all around.

But this was a very well done movie

Posted on December 17, 2005
- Meowan

ungezwungen gut, aber wieso hast du am Filmwettbewerb teilgenommen, wenn dein Film keine der Kriterien erfüllt...wohl verklickt ;)

Posted on December 17, 2005
- Jonomunch

That was good, a bit doom and gloom, but good none the less

Posted on December 17, 2005
- Pupurun

SER SER GUT!!
excellent idea, very poetic with a tremendously good choice of scenes plus editing!!!Soft words but sharp as knives.
S."tookie" Williams R.I.P.
BANN DEATH PENALTY.(TORTURE IS A BETTER PUNISHMENT-just kidding)
/*/*/*/*/*/*/*/*/*/*/*/*/*/*/*/*
Check this if you want to laugh : http://movies.lionhead.com/movie/21430
/*/*/*/*/*/*/*/*/*/*/*/*/*/*/*/*

Posted on December 17, 2005
- Raptor007

Magnificent.

Absolutely Magnificent

Posted on December 17, 2005
- renger6002

Great movie, Great idea, Very emotiional.

ppl plz check out my first movie http://movies.lionhead.com/movie/22286

Posted on December 16, 2005
- gilga

good job , very poetic and i agree a real emotion.
gilga

Posted on December 16, 2005
- Skought

A MASTERPIECE. Superb work. Deeply emotional. I loved it! Nice to see a movie with real emotional connection, not just [bad-word!]y.

Posted on December 16, 2005
- tom123456

Wow!Now im really impressed!You should start a real career!

Posted on December 16, 2005
- ExoticNectar

Hi der Film war echt hammer. Ich bin zu tiefst berührt.Ich bin zwar jemand der bei FIlmen nicht heul aber das hatte qualität die eine oder andere Träne rauszuquetschen. (wäre es ein profi Film^^) Die Musik war sehr gut eingepasst und die Szenen gut zusammengeschnitten, sodass du die Perfekte Stimmung erzeugt hast. Mein Kritikpunkt ist jedoch das Voiceover... wie Willi-Wonka gesagt hat müsste da mehr theatralisches, schauspielermä�?iges hin, um die Stimmung noch mehr an den Höhepunkt zu treiben. Aber lassen wir das

Für sowas kann ich nur fünf Sternchen geben!!!

Posted on December 16, 2005
- Ahmadi_Productions

Script: *****
Narration: ****
Music: ****
Strengths: excellent subject
Weaknesses: the subs

Overall: *****

Posted on December 16, 2005
- castlenaze

Very thoughtful film. Well thought out and presented. Good job.

Posted on December 16, 2005
- movietown

No comment

Posted on December 16, 2005
- MoonShadow74

Excellent movie. I thought it was very well done and very emotional.
Opinion and editorial:
Just remember, people on death row (in the US) are not there for a onetime crime of passion. They are there for murder in the act of another crime or for torturous premeditated murder.

Posted on December 16, 2005
- EgoAnt

I really wish I knew more German, but even without it, even if there had been no subtitles, this movie was well thought out and well executed. The music went well with it and the voice conveyed real sadness. A fantastic little film.

Posted on December 16, 2005
- Yazuac

Ein gefühlvolles Gedicht in einem Film. Sehr schön gemacht, es rührt einen richtig

Posted on December 16, 2005
- el_maraudine

No comment

Posted on December 16, 2005
- Richegroover

First class dialouge. Tidy Short Movie.

Rich

Posted on December 16, 2005
- Philnate

Eindrucksvoll. Gute Arbeit.

Posted on December 16, 2005
- JMMartin

Something unique and touching.It really moved me

Posted on December 15, 2005
- mimymo

No comment

Posted on December 15, 2005
- Cimmerz

Very nice film here. You already addressed the subtitles, which I applaude you for sticking with your vision. It was frustrating to have to pause to read, but the message remained clear. Good job.

Posted on December 15, 2005
- sjefsjef

Red dash gott.!

Posted on December 15, 2005
- richke

nice work...the editing tripped me out a couple of times...but the dialog was superb.

Posted on December 15, 2005
- mory2000

very nice!!
When youve got time look here: http://movies.lionhead.com/movie/21125

Posted on December 15, 2005
- KaeptnWiglo

ganz klasse, geil erzählt - da macht das ansehen spass!!

Posted on December 15, 2005
- teto

No comment

Posted on December 15, 2005
- chiprocks1

Pretty good job!!

Posted on December 15, 2005
- Andy1985

Nicht schlecht, 4 Sterne
Weiter so;)

Sieh dir doch mal meinen neuen Troy McClain Movie an!

Posted on December 15, 2005
- lostwolfnesbit

Originality - ***** Something new for me, letting us see into a condemned man's heart.
Dialogue - ***** I didn't understand a word of the VO, but the subtitles let me know that the dialogue was good, each line leading to the next.
Storyline - ***** I enjoyed it, you knew what you wanted and you accomplished it.
Special effects/sound effects - No Stars, but you didn't need either one or the other for this film, so it won't count against you. The film worked better without them.
Overall - ***** As I said, very original and touching. If we could only see into a condemned man's heart everytime, maybe then we could know what motivates them to do what they did.

Posted on December 15, 2005
- Jedemdo

Rot waren meine Augen, als ich in meiner Kammer diesen Film schaute.

Ganz klar ein Meisterwerk, welches das erste in meinen Links ist!

Posted on December 15, 2005
- KaleeTomey

had to give you a 4 becuase of the subtitles but it really deserves a 5!

Posted on December 15, 2005
- Hump1

von mir gibt es 5 sterne !
top film

Posted on December 15, 2005
- Netschy

wirklich guter film, aber hättest du den höhepunkt musikalisch ruhig noch mehr hervorheben können. trotzdem sehr gute arbeit, weiter so

Posted on December 15, 2005
- Gorgel666

The best movie I´ve seen so far. It really touched me. You are the man!

Posted on December 15, 2005
- CharlieChaplin

Didn't really work for me I'm afraid, not sure why!

Posted on December 15, 2005
- Herr_Lipp

As a story it was good, however it was let down by difficult to read subtitles and also some editing.

Posted on December 15, 2005
- FraasMovies

Echt klasse Film von dir! Sehr gro�?es Lob! Ich bin beeindruckt.

Posted on December 15, 2005
- DrMovie

Nice poetry. Good editing. This deserves a good review.

I am a conservative republican. I am one of those conservative republicans that is avidy against the death penaly. On a legal standpoint, there are obvious flaws in our legal system since it is not uncommon still to this day for people to be wrongly convicted for a crime they didnt commit. Since the horrible reality is at any given time some of the people on death roe are innocent, I feel Life in prison is always the better option.

Unlike life in prison, an execution cannot be reversed after it has been carried out. Unfortunately, it is quite possible that we have murdered innocent people in the past.

Posted on December 14, 2005
- nakedyegg

This is the first movie that i have seen here that made my heart stop. I do not agree with your political views, but I feel your power behind them. Excelent job. Excelent

Posted on December 14, 2005
- Emotep

Very well done. Very artistic. I thought the music enhanced the movie greatly.

Posted on December 14, 2005
- Cranium8768

Very touching, dramatic, nice editing and everything.

Posted on December 14, 2005
- Damien_Hell

Really good! Subtitles went by too quick though

Posted on December 14, 2005
- morpheusneotrinity

Come up with yuor own line by that i mean the end this was very depressing were you trying to do this on purpose i do not now i am sad now however

Posted on December 14, 2005
- ekdahl

I loved the song " Who wants to live forever" Nice pick for this film. I myself am opposed to the death penalty, and against abortion. This definately makes one think! Great job, I would slow down on the subtitles though and not have them appear twice (before and after the fades).

Posted on December 14, 2005
- Silverbullet999

very nice and very powerful.

Posted on December 14, 2005
- Duckguy0100

Excellent movie!! Perfect choice of scenes and narrative.

Posted on December 14, 2005
- Bobmomento

great very unique and very deeply thought out

Posted on December 14, 2005
- oldboy86

ich hab ne gänshaut bekommen............echt jetzt

Posted on December 14, 2005
- Bobaninho

mach weiter so!

Posted on December 14, 2005
- Streberking

Wirklich klasse Film.
Ich bin so begeistert davon das ich trotz der offenkundigen Fehler 5 Sterne geben muss.
1. Nicht mal in den USA wird man für Mord im Affekt hingerichtet.
2. Findest du es nicht ein bisschen zynisch als Hintergrundmusik "who wants to live forever" zu nehmen? (hast du überhaupt die erlaubnis dafür?)

Posted on December 14, 2005
- maarten144

Was a nice movie, though it felt unfinnished. Could have been a much better one if you would 'finish' it.

Posted on December 14, 2005
- Donthecritic

Good movie! Very entertaining! I well organized masterpiece.

Posted on December 14, 2005
- Willy-Wonka

Hey, das ist wieder mal filmerische Top-Qualität - vor allem diese Stimmung ist einfach brilliant eingefangen. Die Sprachaufnahmen haben 'ne schöne Qualität, nur klingt da etwas der Dialekt (der Sauerlands?) durch. Die Musik fügte sich auch perfekt ein, das konnte mich richtig begeistern. Kleinliche Kritik, aber ich muss sie loswerden: Vereinzelt (ich hatte den Eindruck, dass du langsam monotoner wurdest, weil das Satzschema sich wiederholte) hätte der Sprache teilweise noch eine etwas gefühlvollere Betonung, mehr Schauspielerei, gut getan. Am Ende machst du das perfekt, da bringst du die Emotion hervorragend rüber, der ganze Schlu�? ist genial.

Da muss man wirklich nicht lange überlegen: Verdiente 5 Sterne!

Posted on December 14, 2005
- Marx

Minus ten points for using Roy Batty's last spoken words from Blade Runner, couldn't you come up with your own lines?

Posted on December 14, 2005
- cowmansr

Quite powerful. I agree that the subtitles were a bit of an annoyance, making me frequently pause the movie. I don't know how well this could have been avoided though. For bias: I am in most circumstances somewhat opposed to the death penalty. I do wonder in what states this man would have recieved the death penalty for this crime though. Also, I always wonder in these cases why the US is divided as it is, with conservatives being opposed to killing the unborn, but in favor of killing criminals, and liberals into killing the unborn, but wanting to spare the criminals. Why does nobody seek to spare all human life?

Posted on December 14, 2005
- OliverHoffmann

gute arbeit! sehr guter plot! Alles in allem 5 Sterne!

Posted on December 14, 2005
- Fedaredan

Great flick, powerful ending... a lot was hard to keep up with in the subtitles.
-Keep it up!

Posted on December 14, 2005
- Ratqueen

Very artistically made! Great job!

Posted on December 13, 2005
- Patami

handwerklich gut, aber viel zu pathetisch.

Posted on December 13, 2005
- Scottus

Touching. Nice ending with the sounds of electricity. I won't get into the politics of the death penalty here...

Posted on December 13, 2005
- FatherJames

No comment

Posted on December 13, 2005
- izaugg

Beautiful poetry and a worthwhile message. Keep up the good work!

Posted on December 13, 2005
- Electronica

This is the first movie since 'The French Revolution' which really touched me. Very powerful and poetic. The script is a real winner.

Posted on December 13, 2005
- Sam

Very touching and controversial while at the same time offering a plot and story that is going to provoke quite some people I think. The subtitles were edited too quickly maybe but nothing bad. A good movie!

Posted on December 13, 2005
- kaipan

This was an one fine execellent film to tell the simple love story in very creative way! RED is PASSION from your film! Simple yet so powerful, indeed. I loved it.

(Just a little draw back that the faded effects seems overused)

Posted on December 13, 2005
- won_gak

Ok... unglaublich. Ich erspar mir mal meine Kriterienbewertung. Sehr schön geschrieben und verfilmt.

Posted on December 13, 2005
- doerrobst

Gro�?artig - super Umsetzung. Fettes Respekt.

Posted on December 13, 2005
- criMlord

Schöne dramatische Poesie... fett.

Posted on December 13, 2005
- glc-studios

bessere betonung als beim letzten mal.
aktuelles thema! find ich gut!

Posted on December 13, 2005
- McCain

An excelent movie, that is very poetic. You did a fine job here.

Posted on December 13, 2005
- YONDERBOY

Artistically, that was very, very good. Technically, however, the subtitles were pretty darn bad. For subtitles, timing is everything. Having subtitles last for less than 1 second or pop in a half-moment before the fade-out is very disruptive.
Work on that.
However, I really enjoyed the poetry of the movie. You get 5 stars for just how great it was. Next time though, I can't be as generous if the technical aspect isn't up to snuff.

Posted on December 13, 2005
- Mazzoni

That was an excellent movie! I like how you centered everything around the color red. The scene transfers were great as well. Good Job!

Posted on December 12, 2005
- micha83

Sehr gute Arbeit.
Schau mal in meinen neusten Film rein Angel Bet
http://movies.lionhead.com/movie/20464

Posted on December 12, 2005
- gourmelen

That was very poetic.

Posted on December 12, 2005
- Dark_Mace

That was really beautiful. Great work there. Loved the fades to red and back, great use of custom backdrops all round...and creative use of standards scenes for something seemingly different.

Posted on December 12, 2005